Can Ukraine Retake Crimea? A Strategic Case for Long-Term Victory
Can Ukraine Retake Crimea? A Strategic Case for Long-Term Victory
As the war in Ukraine continues to evolve, one of the most hotly debated questions remains: Can Ukraine realistically recapture Crimea from Russian control? Many analysts and politicians have dismissed the idea as fantasy, citing the peninsula’s geography, fortifications, and the anticipated cost in human life. But are they overlooking the long-term strategic picture?
This blog dives deep into the emerging case for why Crimea—while not conquerable today—may fall into Ukrainian hands through patience, strategic attrition, and modern warfare tactics.
The Geography of the Problem
Crimea is uniquely difficult to invade. It juts into the Black Sea and connects to mainland Ukraine through a narrow, easily defensible land corridor. This makes it a nightmare for any conventional land assault. Amphibious beach landings are also unlikely to succeed without catastrophic losses.
Because of this, many Western voices have pushed Ukraine to simply write off Crimea in future peace negotiations.
But Ukraine has refused to yield.
Why Crimea Still Matters
Crimea is not just a symbolic prize—it’s a strategic jewel. It hosts one of the only warm-water, deep-water ports in the Black Sea capable of housing a navy year-round. It’s also a critical logistical hub for projecting power across the region.
For Russia, Crimea provides not only prestige but also a gateway to controlling vital trade routes and military operations in the region. That's why Russia annexed it first in 2014—and why Ukraine still views it as a strategic necessity.
How the Strategic Landscape Has Changed
What the world often misses is that Crimea’s importance and vulnerability have both changed dramatically since the full-scale invasion began in 2022.
Early in the war, Ukraine—despite having virtually no navy—crippled Russia’s Black Sea Fleet using naval drones and long-range missiles. Russian warships were forced to retreat from Crimea, drastically reducing the strategic utility of the peninsula.
Even more important, Ukraine has shown it can maintain shipping routes in the Black Sea despite the fleet’s presence, effectively neutralizing one of Russia’s major advantages.
Crimea: From Fortress to Trap
The same narrow land access and limited supply lines that make Crimea defensible also make it susceptible to siege. Crimea relies heavily on:
The Kerch Strait Bridge (connecting to mainland Russia)
A narrow land corridor through occupied southern Ukraine
A canal system that supplies fresh water
Each of these can be—and in some cases, already has been—targeted or threatened by Ukraine. With the right tools, especially modern drones, Ukraine could isolate Crimea from all sides.
The Siege Strategy
Instead of launching a high-casualty assault, Ukraine could pursue a slow but effective siege strategy:
Cut off the Kerch Bridge – Already struck multiple times, this is a logistical lifeline.
Control the Black Sea – Naval drones have shown that Ukraine can limit maritime resupply.
Deny access to fresh water and fuel – By controlling the canal and rail lines, Ukraine can throttle basic supplies.
Deploy advanced drone swarms – Ukraine is now producing millions of drones annually with growing Western support. These drones could overwhelm defensive positions without direct combat.
In other words, Ukraine doesn’t need to storm Crimea—it can starve it out.
Not Today—But Soon
Is Crimea indefensible today? Probably. But wars aren’t won in a day.
Ukraine is fighting a war of attrition. Its strategy is to hold ground, inflict disproportionate casualties, and wait for cracks to form in Russia’s military and political structure. The goal is to grind down Russian morale, logistics, and political will.
This mirrors what happened to Germany in World War I: a stronghold broken not by force of arms alone, but by sustained economic and military siege.
Why Ukraine Won’t Give Up Crimea
Some argue Ukraine should trade Crimea for peace. But why would they, if they believe victory is achievable through:
Strategic patience
Technological superiority
Moral high ground
International support
Ukraine has demonstrated it can consistently surprise analysts and defy expectations. In the early days of the invasion, many predicted a swift Russian victory. Yet here we are.
The idea that Ukraine can retake Crimea is not hopeful fantasy. It’s a grounded, evolving strategy.
Conclusion: Crimea Is a Matter of When, Not If
When viewed through the lens of attrition warfare, modern drone capabilities, and long-term strategic maneuvering, Ukraine’s path to retaking Crimea becomes clearer.
It’s not about storming the beaches. It’s about slowly turning Crimea into a liability for Russia.
If Ukraine continues its trajectory—expanding drone production, increasing Western support, and maintaining pressure on Russian logistics—the question won’t be if they retake Crimea.
It will be when.
By Rafael Benavent
e